I couldn’t pick three books from the TBR Book Jar this month because the there was no room to fit it into the car for my holiday around Scotland. Fortunately I have all the books listed in a spreadsheet so I asked Mr BookTalk to pick three random numbers for me.

Our Souls At Night by Kent Haruf

This was Haruf’s last novel, and I think may have been published posthumously after his death in 2014. I bought on the strength of recommendations from several book bloggers who saw that I’d enjoyed his earlier novel Benediction. Our Souls at Night is a poignant tale of two neighbours in a small town in the mid West who are brought together by loneliness.

Best of Friends by Kamila Shamsie

Another novel about relationships. This time in the form of a close friendship between two girls in Karachi until an impulsive action one night disrupts their plans for the future. Fourty years later, the past intrudes on their new lives and successful careers in London. Can their friendship survive this new challenge?

Discovery of Heaven by Harry Mulish

I feel very guilty that this book is still on my unread shelf. It was a gift from a former work colleague who knew I was trying to read more internationally and wanted to recommend something from her own country. Mulish is apparently  considered one of the “Great Three” of Dutch postwar writers, an author who injected a lot of philosophy and political views in his novels. The plot for Discovery of Heaven according to the Goodreads summary …

… begins with the meeting of Onno and Max, two complicated individuals whom fate has mysteriously and magically brought together, They share responsibility for the birth of a remarkable and radiant boy who embarks on a mandated quest that takes the reader all over Europe and to the land where all such quests begin and end. Abounding in philosophical, psychological and theological inquiries – yet laced with humour that is as infectious as it is wilful – The Discovery of Heaven convinces us that it just might be possible to bring order into the chaos of the world through a story.

And the vote goes to …….

Which of these three books I read is going to be up to you! In previous months I’ve made the decision myself but I’m drawn to the idea used by Fiction Fan who uses a poll of readers. I hope the poll is going to work — I’ve never used this plug in before.

32 responses to “TBR Book Jar Lucky Dip — June 2024”

  1. I cast my vote for Discover of Heaven by Mulish. I was able to use the poll to cast my vote.

    1. Good to know the poll worked for you Michael. Thanks for taking part

  2. Katrina Stephen Avatar
    Katrina Stephen

    I’ve only just got back from the Netherlands so I would have gone for the Mulish. I hope you have had a good time in Scotland, despite the weather!

    1. We had lovely weather for our first week, then it became very cloudy but even in the mist Scotland had a charm

  3. I’ve had the Mulisch on the TBR for donkeys so I would vote for that. If I could find mine, I might have a go…

    1. Oh please do, then you can explain it to me (I’ve heard it is challenging)

  4. I’ve only come across the Kamila Shamsie title from reviews (mostly favourable) but I guess that’s not enough reason to vote for it! By the way I couldn’t see to access the poll, either on the WP Reader or the internet – but then I tend to stick to a mobile these days rather than a laptop.

    1. I couldn’t see the poll via my iPad either so maybe it doesn’t work on anything other than a computer

  5. I also voted for the Mulish. Oh well…

    1. It doesn’t seem to be the favourite sorry

  6. I also voted for the book by Harry Mulisch. I haven’t read that one, but I did read The Assault by Mulisch which Alice also mentions. It was a very good read.

    1. Thanks Tracyy. If this Mulisch gets picked and I liked it, I’ll have to get The Assault

  7. Haruf is an amazing author. I haven’t read this one yet though, because I felt frustrated that I wouldn’t meet the same characters as the previous two books. But it’s been a while, and now I would be ready to go back to Holt, Colorado. So sad he passed away.

    1. That’s an issue indeed when you grow to love the characters. I wonder if people will feel the same about the books from Elizabeth Strout which all seem to feature the same people or those connected in some way with them

  8. I’m with all the Our Souls at Night votes. Very poignant, especially for those of us “of a certain age.”

    1. Isn’t there a film version also with Robert Redford? Now who could resist him????

  9. I voted for Our Souls at Night, which I finally read last year after multiple recommendations. I’d never read Haruf but you have, so you probably know to expect simple but beautiful and affecting writing … it’s a quick read so you might have time for one of the others as well.

    1. Yes I was struck by the quality of his writing too – he made me feel I really was in Holt

  10. I voted for Best of Friends, which is the only one I’ve read and enjoyed. The other two books do sound interesting, though, and I hope you like whichever one wins.

    1. I’ve read only one book by Shamsie before and did enjoy it. Then I noticed people had mixed views about Best of Friends

  11. My vote is for Our Souls at Night! 💯👍📚

    1. i can see how that would appeal to you Carol

  12. I don’t know why its taken me so long to even think of reading the Haruf because I really enjoyed that small community feel of Benediction

  13. Mulish, I am Dutch!

    1. Have you read this book Alice? I’ve seen some comments that the first 400 pages are good, then it gets all confusing

      1. Read it slowly, it is very heavy on interpersonal relationships, the confusing part is the angels chipping in. If you skip a few of their lines, you do not lose the plot.

        1. Thanks for the advice – since I struggle with any non-human characters in books, this would certainly cause me frustration

      2. If you want a faster read from Mulish, try the Assault, about WWII.

  14. Echoing Margaret with the Haruf. I’ve loved everything I’ve read by him.

    1. That’s a strong endorsement for any author

  15. Our Souls at Night. No question. Haruf has always seemed far too under the radar to me. He’s so very good at small lives in small communities. The Shamsie I enjoyed, but not as much as others In have read of hers. And the Mulish? Don’t know it. Perhaps I should have voted for it, hoped it would win, and read your resulting review!

    1. You’re not alone in thinking the Shamsie wasn’t one of her best.

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading