Every book by Colm Tóbin I’ve read to date has had a female central character. The novella A Long Winter demonstrates without question that he can write from a male perspective just as powerfully.

This is a story about loss and survival told from the perspective of Miquel, a young man in his early twenties. One morning in the depths of winter, his mother goes missing from their home high in the Pyrenees. She’d left in the aftermath of an argument when her husband destroyed her secret supplies of alcohol.

Initial searches reveal only that she’d last been seen walking along a pass out from the nearest village towards her old family home. She never arrived.

As snow falls, covering all roads and obliterating landmarks and tracks, fears grow that she’s perished out on the mountains.

With his younger brother away from home on military service, Miquel and his father falter emotionally and practically. Day after day the same questions bubble through their minds, though are never spoken. Will she ever return? Or will her body be discovered when the snow and ice melt?

Neither of them could cook. His father refused to try but did not stop complaining about the monotony of the food. Too many eggs, he said. Too much cold ham. Miquel tried to cook rice but it came out grainy and hard … the potatoes he boiled seemed to dissolve in the water. … When he tried to cook lentils his father tipped the plate, full of hot food, into the bucket where food for the hens was kept.

Life improves when Manola, an orphaned servant boy from the next village, arrives to cook and clean while Miquel and his father tend to the farm. His arrival marks the beginning of a turning point in Manola’s life. Beneath the surface and amid the silences, emotions run high.

The story ends with exactly the kind of unresolved ending I love. We sense that the love Miquel feels for his mother is, her absence, transferred elsewhere. There’s a glimmer that another kind of life could beckon but it’s by no means certain that this will happen.

A Long Winter is a wonderfully understated novella. There is no wasted dialogue and Tóibín’s use of the landscape and wintry conditions gives the narrative a beautiful melancholic atmosphere.

10 responses to “A Long Winter by Colm Tóibin — Review”

  1. I think whether a book is short or long, whether the language and loose and sprawling and the page count large or spare and tight and novella-length, comes out of what the work needs. I don’t think William Maxwell’s novella So Long See You Tomorrow is aiming to do the same thing that William Faulkner’s wordy novels about conflicts between neighbouring families. But maybe you just have a preference for that spare style? I like both, but have to be in the right mood…

    1. I’ve not read Faulkner so I don’t know whether I’d enjoy him or not. I’m very comfortable with 19th century fiction though which does tend to be on the wordy side. Just like you, I enjoy both though it doe depend on my mood which pulls me in most.

  2. I’ve yet to read this one but the style sound like classic Tóbin. I love that understatement where every word counts.

    1. Me too, it’s a style I wish more contemporary authors would adopt. They’re too often guilty of verbosity

  3. Oh, I loved this. It plunged me into a Pyrennean winter. And as you observe, the unsaid was as potent as what was said.

  4. secretlysuper0e2142c1f9 Avatar
    secretlysuper0e2142c1f9

    Lovely review.  I’d like to read this.Thanks for all your posts. LynSent from my iPad

    1. It’s a gem of a novel

  5. This one is on my wishlist… I really like his stuff:)

  6. I’ve read all of Toibin’s work. Looking forward to reading this. Enticing review!

    1. The only one I’ve read so far but couldn’t get into was The Magician which just dragged on and on

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading