Book Reviews

Benediction by Kent Haruf: life’s small dramas #Book Review

Kent Haruf’s third novel in the Plainsong series reminded me of  the oft-quoted (and misquoted) comment by Henry Thoreau that “the mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.”

Benediction is the final novel in the Plainsong series by Kent Haruf

Set once more In the fictional town of Holt, Colorado, Benediction shows one woman who despairs of life of spinsterhood that awaits her after a scandalous love affair while another is awakened to the shallowness of her relationship with her boyfriend.

Across town, the desperately unhappy son of a minister wants only one thing: to escape this town and return to his former home in Denver. They all have cause to regret missed opportunities and lives that could have been different.

In the midst of all these stories is Dad Lewis, the elderly owner of the town’s hardware store.  The novel opens with the news that he has terminal cancer. It’s a beautifully crafted scene that follows he and his wife as leave the hospital and drive home through wheat fields and wild grass verges, knowing he has one final summer of life ahead. As he waits out his remaining weeks he takes an inventory of his life; weighing up the success of his 50 year marriage and his business, against his failure as a father.

There are ghosts in his past that he wants to lay to rest, regrets he wants to remedy. Outwardly Dad Lewis is rather an ordinary man:

… somebody straight up and down like the hands of a clock…. somebody you could depend on, somebody to trust completely.

This is a man who sets high standards for himself and those around him; a man not afraid to take hard decisions even when they meant hardship for others, but also a man with a good heart, doing what he could to support his neighbours.

For years he secretly supported the widow and son of an employee he was forced to sack for stealing.  Now as he lies dying he puts arrangements in place to help an elderly woman with her gardening and household chores. 

The one ghost that continues to haunt him is his troubled relationship with his estranged homosexual son Frank. Split by anger and misunderstanding they have not seen or spoken to each other for decades. Is it too late for them to make their peace and for Dad Lewis to find redemption?

This isn’t a novel in which a tremendous amount happens. The focus is really on the little dramas of life, or as the town’s Minister describes it “the precious ordinary of life that passes without their knowing it”.  It’s told in an economical style devoid of figurative language but shot through with richly evocative descriptions of landscape and the heat, rain and wind that sweep down on Holt from the Colorado plain.

Haruf’s prose has a quiet power that infuses fairly ordinary actions, turning them into something more grand. There is one wonderful scene for example where three generations of women shake off their inhibitions to skinny dip in a cattle water tank. Haruf suffuses the joy of the physical action with the air of a baptismal celebration.

Benediction by Kent Haruf: Footnotes

Benediction, published by Picador, was the third novel of a series called Plainsong which began with the novel bearing that title, published in 1999. It was followed by Eventide in 2004 and Plainsong in 2014. The books are all set in the fictional town of Holt, Colorado, a location based on  Yuma, Colorado, one of Haruf’s residences in the early 1980s.

Haruf’s last novel was Our Souls at Night, which was published posthumously in 2015. The screen adaptation starred Robert Redford and Jane Fonda.

Kent Haruf died in November 2014, aged 71. In an obituary published in The Guardian newspaper, he was described as a writer of “beautifully restrained, profoundly felt novels”

There’s a good interview with Haruf in the Independent newspaper in which he talks about some of the locations and settings that inspire his writing.


What do you need to know about me? 1. I'm from Wales which is one of the countries in the UK and must never be confused with England. 2. My life has always revolved around the written and spoken word. I worked as a journalist for nine years then in international corporate communications 3. My tastes in books are eclectic. I love realism and hate science fiction and science fantasy. 4. I am trying to broaden my reading horizons geographically by reading more books in translation

15 thoughts on “Benediction by Kent Haruf: life’s small dramas #Book Review

  • I only came across one of Kent Haruf’s books last year, via the Library, Our Souls at Night, which I read and enjoyed. I’d like to read more of his novels – seemingly simple novels, but offering a lot.

    • That’s so true Alison. If you described the plot to someone they might well end up thinking the book is rather underwhelming but behind the simplicity he packs in a lot to think about

  • I must catch up. I read Plainsong and the book in that series that followed it, but not this one. And Our Souls at Night just about broke my heart. What a fine writer Haruf was. Thanks for your review.

    • I’ve no idea why I picked this oen given its the last in the series – seems a very odd thing for me to do. So now I do want to go back to the beginning

  • This post has me stumped, Karen. I’ve tried all sorts of tweeting methods but every time it comes up with a Page Not Found notice. Most peculiar! 🤔

    • Glad it isn’t just me. I might just update the date on the post and see what happens

  • Lovely review, Karen. Haruf’s writing is superb. He says so much in a few perfectly chosen words.

    • I don’t know why I haven’t read more by him because I did love his quiet style

  • I love his style, definitely need to read this one as well. Great review

    • What else have you read by him? I have Our Souls At Night but nothing else

  • Pingback: Sonntagsleserin KW #11 – 2014 | buchpost

  • Ooh, sounds like a wonderful book. Must try to pick it up sometime.

    • i’d never heard of this author before this book but he seems to have a very loyal set of followers.

  • Oooh, this is on my TBR! It’s rare that I find someone else has the same book as me!

    • think of yourself as being in very elite company – why do what everyone else does?


We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.