I joined the Classics Club in 2012. I confess that it took me a lot longer than the “required” five years to read 50 books from my initial list. Eight years in fact. I’m now on list number two which I started in June 2022 and from which I’ve read 19 to date.

I’m not a planner so don’t tend to know what I’m going to read next. From my Classics Club list my next pick might (but only might) be either Thirty Nine Steps by John Buchan, The Wings of the Dove by Henry James or Of Human Bondage by Somerset Maugham.

I don’t have any 1926 titles in my list.

Oh this is a tough question when I’ve read many outstanding books from my lists. I’ll pick a couple from each list. L’Assommoir  by Émile Zola and All Passion Spent  by Vita Sackville West  from list one and  A Thousand Cranes by Yasunari Kawabata and Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier  from list two.

Émile Zola takes top billing for the author I’ve read most. I’ve just finished reading The Dream which is the sixth book to date of us that I’ve read.

Probably one we had to read in school the title of which has long been forgotten. I went off piste when I was sixteen and began a phase of borrowing books from the library by authors from around the world. I understood barely a fraction of them but enjoyed the experience of reading Nausea by Jean Paul Sartre and The Outsider by Albert Camus.

It might have been Treasure Island but could equally have been Black Beauty. Childhood was so long ago I can’t honestly remember.

I’ll pick Crime and Punishment by  Fyodor Dostoevsky  because of the circumstances in which I read this book. I took it on a transatlantic flight and was so hooked on the book that I was annoyed when we landed and I had just five pages left to read. I wanted to stay in my seat and finish it, but the crew had other ideas.

Obviously this would be one of the books I never finished. Like The Man Who Knew Too Much by G. K Chesterton or Tender is the Night by Ernest Hemingway.F Scott Fitzgerald (corrected thanks to WordsandPeace)

It would have to be the 1995 BBC adaptation of Pride and Prejudice with Jennifer Ehle and Colin Firth in the lead roles.

Juliet Barker’s biography of the Brontë sisters impressed me so much when I read it in 1994 that I kept it and it’s still on my bookshelves.

As answered in question 4, this would be Émile Zola. Though I’ve read ten of his novels to date there are another ten left to read in his Rougon-Marquet cycle. 

I can’t say that I do, beyond the obvious answer of Shakespeare.

Maybe Jo March from Little Women because of her love of reading and also her messy habits.

The oldest I’ve read was Medea by Euripedes which dates from about 431 BC. In my current list the oldest is Belinda by Maria Edgeworth, published in 1801.

None. When a novel is over, it’s over even if it ends without full resolution. I like to use my own imagination about what could happen next to the characters.

Oxford World Classics is my preferred choice for Zola’s novels. I love the artwork on the cover and find the introductions insightful. For more modern classics I do love the Virago Modern Classics editions (the ones with the green covers)

Middlemarch I’ve read six times now, Pride and Prejudice about four times. For me a true definition of a classic is a novel you can read and re-read and find something new in it each time. I just wish I had more time to go back to some of my old favourites.

There have been many over the years. I gave up on Pamela by Samuel Richardson having struggled through a quarter of it; Tale of Two Cities went the same way. I’ve tried reading that book four times now and have abandoned it at pretty much the same point each time. It’s clearly not one for me.

Cannery Row was an eye-opener for me. I’d always thought Steinbeck just wrote gloomy tales like Grapes of Wrath so it was a revelation to discover the humour in this novella

My favourites are book blogs that offer insightful reviews, often of books I’ve not read or authors I’ve not come across before. Take a blow please:

I might have done one readalong via LibraryThing back in the early days of this blog. I didn’t enjoy it very much because the pace of reading was out of kilter with my own. Some weeks I was ahead of the schedule and other weeks, a long way behind so it made the online discussions complicated.

I did sign up in 2022 to do a readlong of Voss by Patrick White hosted by Brona (one of the Classic Club moderators). Real life intervened and I never got very far into the novel — my bookmark is still in place however ready for the day when I pick up the book once more.

Based on my (admittedly limited) experience I don’t think I’m in a hurry to join another readalong

It’s the sense of connection with like minded people all around the world that I appreciate the most. We may be reading different books but we are united by our love of good fiction.

A calendar of events could be helpful so I know when the Classics Club spin will be held for example. I always seem to get caught out and then scramble to get the list done and the reading done in time.

Which classic author (or novel) would you choose as your Desert Island companion? Mine would be Middlemarch by George Eliot.

26 responses to “Under the Spotlight: 26 Questions from The Classics Club”

  1. I enjoyed reading your answers! I wish I had more time for re-reading too – apart from my annual Dickens re-read, I seem to be unable even to fit in all-time favourites like Austen these days. I’m impressed at your Zola reading – your reviews of his books are what really put him on my radar, and I hope to read more of him on my next CC list. On a different subject, are you planning to do Reading Wales again this year?

    1. Yes definitely Reading Wales will happen again in March. So glad you are interested enough to want to do it again. We’re just weighing up some choices for a group read.

      1. March? Gosh, I thought it was April – glad I asked! I shall juggle my reading schedule around – I’ve got one that I’m hoping turns out to be as good as it sounds… 😀

  2. Loved your Crime & Punishment story Karen! And I think it was in part thanks to you that I ‘discovered’ Zola – Germinal is still the standout for me, although L’Assommior was unforgetable too.

    A calendar of events is a great idea – thanks 🙂

    1. Germinal has a special place in my affection – not just because it was the first Zola I read but it’s set in a mining community. My grandfathers and uncles were all coal miners so it resonated with me on that level

  3. My suggestion to anyone who is hesitant about reading Middlemarch (either because of its length or they think it could be challenging) is to think of it like a soap opera. You can follow the different characters who are in relationships and notice how their relationships differ. Or you can read it as a novel about ambition and how it is often thwarted.

  4. Fascinating answers, Karen, and I applaud your answer to question 16 – and I’d also apply it to most fan fiction, either by amateurs or professionals (with one or two exceptions, such as the prequel Wide Sargasso Sea). I’ve both hosted and joined in with readalongs, even done ‘shadow’ readalongs, but like you I prefer to read at my own pace and not be bound by an external imperative.

    Oh, and thank you for the appreciation, and of course I return the compliment: I enjoy your critiques, your ‘no nonsense’ ones as well as your appreciative reviews!

    1. I’m not a fan of prequels/sequels or spin offs. Maybe this is unfair to the author but I feel it’s lazy to take another person’s idea for plot/character and use that as the basis for your own novel. Why not exercise your own imagination instead of riding on someone else’s coat tails

  5. Oh wow, Middlemarch! I actually DNFed it!
    Did Hemingway also write a book called Tender is the Night?
    Here are my answers: https://wordsandpeace.com/2026/01/14/the-classics-club-26-questions-in-2026/

    1. Thanks for spotting my error. It was F Scott Fitzgerald who wrote Tender is the Night. Neither author has a style that I find enjoyable

  6. I enjoyed reading your answers. Good to see you were so impressed by Juliet Barker’s biography of the Brontë sisters because I bought a copy several years ago but still haven’t read it. I’ve just checked -horrified to see I’ve had it for nearly ten years! I really must get round to it soon. Cannery Row was the first book I read by Steinbeck and I loved it. I also loved The Grapes of Wrath, even though it is gloomy, but such a good story. I haven’t read anything by Zola, where do you think it’s best to start? I loved Middlemarch, and I want to reread it, but it is so long, and there are so many books I want to read, that I can’t see me doing that any time soon.
    And thanks for mentioning my blog!

    1. Where to start with Zola? An easy entry point would be The Ladies Paradise which is set in Paris and goes into a lot of detail about a department store. It’s not as challenging as some of his other titles. I started with Germinal and found it rivetting

      1. Thanks, I’ll have a look at it and at Germinal too.

        1. I hope to get to the end of the year and find I’ll have converted you to Zola

  7. It was nice to read your answers, I agree on that sense of community, and I also have a very remarkable experience with Crime and Punishment.

    1. Would love to know the details of that Crime and Punishment experience Silvia.

      1. Really? Here you have it. I was a young woman in Madrid, Spain, studying Philosophy at the University Complutense in Madrid. My friends and I were readers, and some had read Crime and Punishment. Despite being a bit intimidated, I started to read it. I still remember vividly carrying the sense of guilt of the protagonist. Also seeing how lied trap you and like him, thinking everyone knew. I have later on read The Gambler (so dark for me since my parents gamble for some time that I can’t read it again), The Idiot and The Brothers Karamazov. I always remember where I was in life, and the rooms I was at while reading these books.

        1. Lies not lied (typo)

        2. Loved your story about how the book affected you. Some of the books I remember most come attached with the memory of where I was reading each one.

  8. Great answers and we do share some titles in common, like Cannery Row (although I loved The Grapes of Wrath!); I have Zola on my list but haven’t chosen a particular title yet, would you start at the beginning of the series?

  9. A really interesting Q&A – thank you for sharing. I’m impressed that you’ve read Middlemarch so many times, but I know that the books we loves are ones we can read over and over. I like the idea of the Classics Club, but I know I would never stick to a list so I guess I’ll continue to read the classics when my reading mood takes me to them (which is reasonable often!) Glad to hear the Juliet Barker Bronte book is so good as I do have a copy of that on my shelves!

    1. Well two of those re-reads happened because it was on the syllabus for an Open University module I took. But I loved it so much I wanted to read it for pleasure also.
      The good thing about the Classics Club is that you can change your mind. Yes you do make a list to begin with but there’s nothing to say you can’t delete/add – which in fact is what I’ve done. I use it as a guideline not a fixed reading programme. I also have more than 50 on my list to give me extra flexibility

  10. Is there such a thing as a “classics light” reader? I try to read or reread one classic per year, but I’m in a different league than you!

    1. Even one or two a year is more than many people

  11. It’s funny, you love Middlemarch yet I’ve always been “afraid” of it. My top pick, Gone With the Wind scares all kinds of people. Maybe I’ll try Middlemarch. Cannery Row is a bit different than the normal Steinbeck gloom. #9 you might want to put F. Scott Fitizgerald as the author of Tender is the Night . No worries, I’m not your literature teacher! Very good answers. I agree on a calendar of events for Classics Club. I usually learn of a Spin when someone I read regularly does their post.

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading