The Hog’s Back Mystery by Freeman Wills Crofts [book review]
The Hog’s Back Mystery is a gem of a book for readers who enjoy crime fiction, prefer it to come sans details of bloody corpses, tortured victims or nasty things lurking in the woodshed but don’t want it to veer too much towards “cosy”.
It’s one of the titles republished in the British Library Classic Crime series and comes from what’s been labelled as the Golden Age of Detective Fiction (a term coined by the writer John Strachey in 1939 to describe crime novels written between the world wars). These authors followed certain conventions, chief of which was that readers shouldn’t be cheated by sudden revelations or surprises. No-one to whom the reader hadn’t already been introduced should be revealed as the murderer for example.
In The Hog’s Back Mystery author Freeman Wills Crofts this plays scrupulously fair with his readers. Every detail the armchair sleuth could possibly need to make their own deduction is provided. His detective in charge of the investigation, Inspector Joseph French of Scotland Yard, helpfully recaps and reviews his findings every few days. To play even more fair with his readers, when the crime is finally solved he provides the page numbers for every clue in the trail, a detailed timetable of events and a little sketch map. It still took me three quarters of the book to get an inkling of the identity of the perpetrator but I never got close to working out how the crime was committed.
I say crime but in fact this book has four. It begins with the disappearance of a semi-retired doctor from his home in the vicinity of The Hog’s Back, a ridge on the North Downs in Surrey. Doctor Earle left the house in slippers and minus hat one evening. Had he been abducted or murdered? Or was his disappearance planned? The mystery deepens when a nurse who he had met secretly in London also disappears. One theory holds that they had run off together but then a house guest of the doctor and his wife also vanishes.
Solving this puzzle requires all of French’s skills in getting people’s confidence so they open up to him and disclose seemingly small and inconsequential details about their movements at the time of the disappearances. They build a picture of an era and a way of life that most of us wouldn’t recognise today. The buses run so punctually that an alibi can be built around them and telegrams popped into a rural postbox will reach its city destination promptly. The families and individuals in this novel dress for dinner; eat a substantial lunch as well as dinner except for Sunday’s when it’s their cook’s day off so they take a cold collation and the men smoke a lot. French has a healthy appetite himself and is concerned that the quality of his work will fall away if he is hungry. Fortunately in this investigation he gets to do a lot of cycling between different houses, borrowing a lowly constable’s bike to do so. Could you imagine Inspector Morse’s reaction if told to forgo his beloved Jag for a two-wheeler?
There are a plethora of suspects, a multitude of dead ends to navigate and some complex alibis for him to evaluate before he can wrap everything up and help bring the guilty to justice. In the introduction to the British Library edition, the crime fiction expert Martin Edwards, indicates that Freeman Wills Crofts wrote an essay in which he described his method for constructing his plots. Apparently he first prepared a synopsis of the “facts” and the chronology of events then sketch maps of key locations and character biographies. Finally he developed a summary of how and when the facts are revealed to his investigator. I have to believe such meticulous attention to detail is linked with his training as a civil engineer, an occupation which requires precision and logic. It meant that by the time I got to the end of The Hog’s Back Mystery I didn’t have that feeling I so often experience with crime novels, that I’d been cheated and led up a garden path.
About this book: The Hog’s Back Mystery by Freeman Wills Crofts was first published in 1933. It was his fourteenth novel and the fifth to feature Inspector French.
About the author: Freeman Wills Crofts was born in Dublin in 1879. At seventeen he began studying civil engineering and developed a passion for railway engineering. He began writing to amuse himself while recovering from an illness, initially combining his new career with his work as chief engineer for an Irish railway company. Such was the success and esteem of his novels that he gave up the railway work.
Why I read this book: I learned of this book via Ali at HeavenAli (her review is here) and she kindly donated her copy to me. I added it to my #20booksofsummer reading list for 2017. It was ideal reading for my period of enforced leisure after my broken humerus adventure.
24 thoughts on “The Hog’s Back Mystery by Freeman Wills Crofts [book review]”
Pingback: Incoming Books (and Their Sources) – findingtimetowrite
Pingback: Reading Bingo 2017 | BookerTalk
Pingback: Mysterious Happenings on the South Downs | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
Pingback: #20booksofsummer 2017 wrap up | BookerTalk
I do love the British library crime classics and this one sounds particularly tempting!
its well worth reading
how dare you recommend a book by a PROLIFIC author?? ouch to my TBR!!!
So glad you enjoyed this so much. The British Library Crime Classics are a great provider of clever mysteries like this one.
some seem rather better than others according to my sister who has read far more than I have
Yes, I suppose that will always be the case with such a large number of re-issues.
you seem to have found a few of the better ones so those are the titles I recommended to sister
I enjoyed this one too. His books are so carefully worked out, which is more than can be said for many crime fiction writers.
I’ve read my fair share of books where you get to the end and read the solution and just feel exasperated by all the loose ends remaining
Croft was one of the names I read when I first started exploring Golden Age crime many moons ago, and I think his reputation has surived better than some of the others. Fortunately, I can remember nothing about which ones of his I’ve read, and I also have this one on my shelves!
I would be encouraged to read more by him on the strength of this one Karen.
This sounds very appealing. I like this collection a great deal.
I’ve read only one other author in the reprints – it was by John Bude and while it was ok I think acrobats is superior. Anything you would recommend Caroline?
I love Gil North. Absolutely loved it. I kept the second for later.
Ive come across that name while browsing in the bookshop. Will pay closer attention next time
This does sound like one of the better books in the BLCC collection – with a satisfying conclusion to boot. I’ll definitely be looking out for this in the local charity/second-hand shops as they tend to crop up on a fairly regular basis.
I would offer you my copy but unfortunately my sister snaffled it already thinking it perfect for her long and probably sleepless nighttime flight to Sri Lanka
Sounds great! I’ve only read one book by Freeman Wills Croft – another of the BL collection, The 12.30 from Croydon. Although it is an Inspector French book, he’s barely in it. It’s done from the perspective of the murderer, which apparently was pretty ground-breaking at the time, and looks at the planning of the crime and then the aftermath as the criminal suffers a kinf of horror at his own actions, combined with the fear of getting caught. I thoroughly enjoyed it and will definitely want to read more of his stuff. But then I want to read all these BL books…
That sounds a good one. Shall put it on my list