Book Reviews

The Bowery Slugger by Leopold Borstinski: Danger On The Streets Of New York

The Bowery Slugger by Leopold Borstinski

The Bowery was a dangerous place to live in New York in the early 1900s. Gangs ruled the streets and controlled the unions. They also exerted their influence over their elected representatives and government officials.

It was the roughest neighbourhood in Manhatten.

Along certain sections of the road in the Lower East side, each building was occupied by either a gambling den, whorehouse or bar. Sometimes they combined to meet the needs of a man who had many vices to fulfill at the same time.

It was also a place of opportunity for a young man with a sharp brain and a willingness to use his fists . Such a man is the key figure in The Bowery Slugger; Alex Cohen, a Jewish immigrant boy who muscles his way into the gangs and become the notorious “Slugger”.

Alex is one of thousands of European immigrants drawn to New York “not speaking the language but hoping, beyond hope, this land of opportunity would deliver plenty to them.” The Cohens had been driven from their small wooden home in the Ukraine because of religious persecution by the Russians.

The promised land they expect to find in New York doesn’t deliver. The Cohens end up in small, run down apartment in a tall tenement building in The Bowery. Alex’s father fails to find work as a tailor so it’s down to their son to help them pay for food and accommodation.

He’s a resourceful boy who in the Ukraine had already learned “how to read people and to persuade them to bend to his will.” It’s fortunate that on his first night in the city he finds a way into a trickster operation. From there he progresses to the loan shark ‘business’ and then extortion, becoming a heavy man for one of the big gangs.

The Bowery Slugger traces his life over the course of three years. It’s an episodic novel full of incidents in which Alex becomes a force to be reckoned with in the neighbourhood. He’s never far from violence. Anyone who displeases him is liable to get their nose smashed, their jaw broken or their neck slashed.

This kind of narrative could easily become very tedious especially since I’m not a fan of violence. But Leopold Borstinski’s novel has two significant redeeming features that kept me reading.

First up was the detail of life in this area of New York in the first decade of the twentieth century. You really get the sense of how difficult it was for immigrants to find a footing in the city.

There’s a suggestion right at the beginning of the book of an anti Jewish feeling with landlords unwilling to rent to those families. Naturally the Cohens feel more comfortable amid people of their own kind, particularly since they have little command of English. The Bowery Slugger is full of Yiddish expressions which I thought brought a level of authenticity to the dialogue.

The other element of The Bowery Slugger that I enjoyed was the character of Alex. What Borstinski gives us is a young man with a dilemma. He needs to keep in with the gang leaders to support his family but as the violence escalates he gets increasingly worried about what he is getting into. He also finds himself in love with the young girl who lives in the same apartment block. But she won’t marry him unless he gives up his gangster life. It’s the conflict between these different aspects of his life that make the book interesting but I think it could have been developed even further.

Even though Alex was a thoroughly nasty character, I was invested enough in him to what to know how this conflict would be resolved. We don’t get to find out because, right at the end, Borstinski engineers a plot development that leaves Alex’s future open for the next book in the series. I won’t spoil the fun by giving away the details. I’ll say only that Alex might think this is a way out of his problems but actually he is about to get himself involved in a whole new heap of trouble.

Crime noir is outside my normal reading fare but The Bowery Slugger was an engaging blend of dynamic action and period detail topped off with a morally questionable character.

The Bowery Slugger: Fast Facts

The Bowery Slugger is the first book in a series featuring the Jewish gangster, Alex Cohen. It was published in paperback and e-book format by Sobriety Press on 10th November 2019.

Leopold Borstinski

Leopold Borstinski turned to writing after a varied career in financial journalism, business management and teaching.
He is drawn to stories about the morally questionable and to characters who are morally suspect.
His previous work includes the Lagotti Family series, six crime noir novels set in 1960s Baltimore.



What do you need to know about me? 1. I'm from Wales which is one of the countries in the UK and must never be confused with England. 2. My life has always revolved around the written and spoken word. I worked as a journalist for nine years then in international corporate communications 3. My tastes in books are eclectic. I love realism and hate science fiction and science fantasy. 4. I am trying to broaden my reading horizons geographically by reading more books in translation

15 thoughts on “The Bowery Slugger by Leopold Borstinski: Danger On The Streets Of New York

  • Pingback: From English seaside to Nigerian city: 6 Degrees of Separation : BookerTalk

  • Pingback: My 2019 Life In Books : BookerTalk

  • I couldn’t help but be reminded of the Scorsese film, The Gangs of New York, as I was reading your review. The Scorsese is set in the mid 19th century, but the subject matter is similar.

    • I’d be unlikely to see that film though I’ve herd of it – I hate anything with violence (have to hide behind the cushion or leave the room at that point)

  • I’ve often enjoyed New York immigrant stories from the first half of the 1900s. This does sound pretty good.

    • Just be aware that there are multiple incidents of violence – I know that is something many people don’t like to see when they are reading. They are not told in detail and are over in seconds but they are there in quantity

  • This definitely isn’t my usual reading fare. I can’t help be get whiffs of Scarface and The Godfather. However, I also know they ethnic ghettos were all over New York during the immigration boom because citizens were so afraid of people stealing their jobs, corrupting their values, bringing diseases, etc. We’re a terrified people, we Americans. Still are.

    • I knew there was a distinctive Irish quarter in the city – some of the poorest neighbourhoods. Those fears can also be found in UK when the famine drove 000s of people from Ireland. There were riots in some places as a result. We still see those attitudes playing out in the whole Brexit fiasco

  • Like you, this isn’t necessarily a book I’d pick up but it sounds like there’s enough in it to make it worthwhile! 😀

    • Without the setting and detail about the period I wouldn’t have even opened the book

  • I read a great book earlier this year, The Last Pirate of New York, that also took place in this time period in NYC. So fascinating!

    • Thanks to you for the opportunity to take part in the blog tour….


We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: