My book jar experiment was such a success in 2023 that I’m going to continue using this to choose which books to read from my extensive TBR shelves.

On the first day of each month I’ll pick out three titles from the jar (eyes closed so I can’t cheat) and commit to reading one of them within the following two months. I thought I’d start to share with you all what comes out of the jar and which title I’ll choose to read.

So here goes. This being January 1 I’ve drawn three new titles in the lucky dip. This is what’s on offer this month.

Frog by Mo Yan

This was one of the titles I choose to keep when it featured in a Sample Sunday post. It’s been on my shelves since 2016.

The novel by the Nobel Laureate tells the story of a woman whose life spans the Japanese occupation of China, the years of communist rule and then the beginning of state-directed capitalism. At one point she acts as the midwife in her village, having to perform late-term abortions to prove her allegiance to the communist rulers and their strict one-child policy.

A Room Full of Leaves by Kate Grenville

One of the many (too many) books I requested from Net Galley and then failed to read. This one dates from 2020, requested because I’d enjoyed a previous novel by Grenville — The Secret River.

A Room Full of Leaves is a mix of fact and fiction about Elizabeth Macarthur, wife of John Macarthur who was apparently a highly influential (but controversial) figure in the establishment of the colony of New South Wales. Grenville uses letters sent by Elizabeth to her family and friends in England to reveal the “truth” about her life with a man who seems to have been rather a thug.

Hostages to Fortune by Elizabeth Cambridge

I bought this as a Persephone edition in a National Trust secondhand bookshop in 2019. It was in pristine condition and a bargain at £2 so even though I knew nothing about the book or the author it was impossible to resist.

I’ve since learned that it’s an autobiographical first novel, published in 1933, which follows the life of a doctor’s wife in a small Cambridge village, It doesn’t have a plot as such but is more a domestic narrative that reflects on a way of life in the period between 1915 and 1933 when the book was published. Persephone describes it as “A quiet, beautifully-written novel …”

And the vote goes to …….

Hostages of Fortune

It was a close run contest between this and Frog but Elizabeth Cambridge won just because the book is so beautifully published. A glorious coral/pink endpaper (with matching bookmark) and heavy weight off white paper stock give it a wonderful tactile and visual appeal while the text is surrounded by a lot of white space making it easier to read.

So now all I have to do is read the book — I have until end of March. If it’s not read by then, as per my own “rules” it will have to be given away.

27 responses to “TBR Book Jar — January 2023 lucky dip decision”

  1. Oh, I’m so glad you’re continuing with the TBR jar! It’s such a fun way to spice things up. And selfishly I hope that A Room Made Of Leaves gets another chance in the jar for some future month – I didn’t think it would be my kind of thing, and then had to eat a big heaping serve of my own words when I read it. I see plenty of others pushing for the biography instead, but I loved the way Grenville imagined a whole other life for her.

    1. Thanks for the vote in favour of Grenville’s novel. Honestly I wouldn’t ever get to read the biography!

  2. Hopefully I can start doing this as well in February. Planning to be more spontaneous, but January was already too full to even put this, I think.
    https://wordsandpeace.com/2024/01/01/the-top-7-books-to-read-in-january-2024/

  3. Good choice and good luck!

    1. Thanks Karen. I’ve enjoyed the first few pages I sampled

    1. Thanks so much for thinking of me – that’s really kind of you

      1. I’m a librarian–I squirrel stuff away and then finally recall who it is that’s interested in it. 🙂

        1. A good skill to have!

  4. In my early blog years, I tried a TBR Book Jar – lasted about 2 months – I always managed to pick the titles I least wanted to read! Good luck with it. 😀

    1. My first jar wasn’t a success – I kept trying to cheat by putting back the titles I didn’t want to read. This time around, by giving myself 3 options and being very firm with myself, it feels easier

  5. I enjoyed the Grenville, but agree with the others who say it’s not her best – and I did enjoy the bio of Elizabeth Macarthur by Michelle Scott Tucker. I’d like to read Hostages to Fortune sometime.

  6. My book jar is my saving grace. I don’t know how I decided what to read before I had one.

  7. Interesting choices – but do please read the Kate Grenville at some point. As always with her, it’s a worthwhile and enjoyable read. Though I’d agree with other commenters – not absolutely her best.

    1. i will get around to it at some point though may not be this year…..

  8. Now I have read A Room Made Of Leaves, I gave it 4 stars. I was more interested in the sheep breeding aspect, which sadly was only touched upon a few times. I kept expecting much more about it.

    1. Sheep breeding wouldn’t hold much appeal for me but then I might be pleasantly surprised by it 🙂

  9. Lyn Leader-Elliott Avatar
    Lyn Leader-Elliott

    I’d make the same choice if I had all three on hand. I’ve read the Grenville; it’s not as good as her others and like Lisa, I’d head for the biography. I read Red Sorghum by Mo Yan and found his unsparing descriptions of unspeakable cruelties so harrowing g I have never wanted to revisit his world.

    1. Oh dear, I have Red Sorghum on my shelves. Better save that for a time when the weather is less gloomy. I don’t think I could take the combination of cruelty and the British winter weather

  10. The jar is so fun; glad it’s keeping going! And Hostages to Fortune is one of my favourite Persephones – absolutely brilliant.

    1. That’s encouraging to hear Simon. I read the opening pages and enjoyed them so am looking forward to getting stuck in.

  11. That’s such a good idea! Enjoy whatever your “lottery” gives you this year.

    1. it’s working well so far….I’m getting on better with this lottery idea than making a long list and trying to tick off all the books

  12. Good choice. (I’ve read a lot of Grenville, but not that one because I’d already read an excellent bio of Elizabeth Macarthur by Michelle Scott Tucker.)
    But Frog interests me. Do I already have it?
    *pause, checks Excel TBR file*
    No. I have two others. Better read them first before buying another one!

    1. I’ve never read anything by Mo Yan but I’m intrigued to find out that despite being critical of the Chinese regime he hasn’t been imprisoned.

      1. I’ve only read Radish by Mo Yan, but quite a few by Yan Lianke. He gets away with it through satire.
        And in one book, The Explosion Chronicles, he has numbered the footnotes with every alternate number missing, to show that there’s something not said and you have to join the dots yourself. It’s very clever.

        1. I know I wouldn’t be clever enough to work that out without help from other readers

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading