I cancelled my Audible subscription some months back when I discovered that my subscription plan wouldn’t allow me to download files and listen off line. So for entertainment/distraction while in the gym I’ve had to rely on the audiobook options available via my local library service.

They’e not wonderful — the selection is very heavily weighted towards thrillers, crime and popular authors like Lucinda Riley. For anything decent you have to join a very long reservations queue. These three were the best options available at the time.

The Maid by Nita Prose

In Nita Prose’s debut novel, a naive maid in a high class hotel solves the mystery about a wealthy guest found dead in his suite.

Molly Gray is a model employee at the Regency Grand. Every day, armed with a fully stocked cart of miniature soaps and bottles, she delights in returning guest rooms “to a state of perfection.” Order and routine help her make sense of the world.

Her carefully managed life is thrown into chaos the day she finds the fabulously wealthy guest Charles Black, dead in his bed and she becomes the lead suspect.

The plot is far fetched — there’s no hard evidence to implicate her, just hints from other hotel workers and Molly’s strange responses when questioned by police.

Molly’s old-fashioned turns of phrase and tendency to answer with precision, may indicate neurodiversity. I’m not qualified to guage that but I would have thought a police officer with an ounce of intelligence would have considered that possibility.

The Maid isn’t a book I would have read normally but it served the purpose of distracting me from the time remaining clock on the treadmill.

The Grey Wolf by Louise Penny

This is the 19th novel in Louise Penny’s bestselling series featuring Chief Inspector Armand Gamache of the Sûreté du Québec. The series has become increasingly wide ranging it its themes and locations with each new title.

In The Grey Wolf the plot is focused on a bio-toxin terrorist threat to the water supply of Montreal. It begins — and ends — in the familiar cosy territory of the Three Pines village but travels far and wide in between. As Gamache and his trusted deputies race to prevent the attack, they take in  Québec, Washington, The Vatican and a secluded monastery in France.

As always with Penny’s novels, the plot is complex, weaving together seemingly disparate pieces of info that lead readers down many dead ends. A missing coat and a possible intruder in Gamache’s apartment, somehow link to the ingredients for Chartreuse liqueur and political ambition.

There was a touch too much of the thriller element for me as the novel drew to its close. I’ve always found the enjoyment of the series lies in the character of Armand Gamache. He’s a less showy detective than most you encounter in crime fiction, a man confident in his abilities but also conscious of his failings. In The Grey Wolf he’s turned into an action man hero which seems so much at odds with the thoughtful, wise man man of the previous books.

The Black Wolf by Louise Penny

The Grey Wolf ended with the arrest of the person behind a threat to poison the public water system of Montreal. It should have been a time for celebration but weeks after the arrest, Gamache begins to doubt whether the man they called The Black Wolf, the man now in prison, really was the mastermind. Is there indeed an even greater threat lurking?

Once more his team swing into action. This time, their inquiries lead them take them to the pinnacles of power in law enforcement, industry, organized crime and government. It’s not just the future of one city at stake, nor just one country.

So having seen Gamache as the saviour of Montreal in The Grey Wolf, now in The Black Wolf he’s the saviour of his country if not the world. Ridiculous.

I have four books still to read from the earlier part of the series. I may still keep them for those days when I want something undemanding but otherwise I’m done with this series.

19 responses to “Review round up: Nita Prose & Louise Penny”

  1. I read the first in Penny’s Gamache series, Still Life, 8 years ago because someone I knew at the time loved this series. While I found it well-plotted and enjoyable, it didn’t convince me to proceed further with the series. Given your reviews, I am glad I didn’t! 🙂

    I admit that I do totally enjoy Nita Prose’s Molly the Maid series!

    1. I think the first eight or so books in the series were the best. The more recent ones are starting to seem formulaic.

  2. Thanks for ‘reading’ these so I don’t have to, but I’m sorry if they proved to be more a disappointment than a pleasant distraction.

    1. I’m fine with reading some lighter novels in between the more meaty ones – my brain does need a break now and again.

  3. In the early days of my blog there were quite a few reviews of audio books because I used them at the gym too (and also on the daily commute). My source was also the library and I had the same problem. Not entirely the library’s fault that options were so limited, back then audio books were very expensive presumably because they were expensive to produce and so the companies that published them produced titles that were going to sell i.e. popular genre fiction. I didn’t really mind because I didn’t want anything I really had to concentrate on anyway.
    But although they now have a lot of audio books on shelf for borrowing they’re still the same kind of books, and the few classics my library had, have disappeared.
    Audible is wickedly expensive for what it is. Here in Oz it’s $9 p/m, i.e. $108 p.a. and at the end of it, it’s like every other streaming service, you’ve got nothing.

    1. I do understand that the library providers go with what their members enjoy most but they should also take account of other interests.

      Audible worked fine when I first used it – I could download the files to my laptop and listen whenever I wanted, often months after I used my monthly credit. They helped keep me sane on long flights..
      But now they’ve changed the system and I can’t get that to work. So if you do select a book using your credit, you have to read it by a certain date or it just disappears

      1. I bet they didn’t reduce the cost.

        1. You are correct!

  4. Alas, I had to stop listening to the Gamache series. I stopped the one before this, as they were getting so so dark for me

    1. I didn’t have an issue with them being too dark, they were just over the top. I think she got carried away with her collaboration with Hilary Clinton

  5. “a police officer with an ounce of intelligence” – funny, not funny

  6. I tried Audible a few years ago but decided I’d rather read than listen. I get distracted if I’m doing something else at the same time but I can see it would be good at the gym. I’ve never read any of Louise Penny’s books, but wondered if I’d like them – I don’t think I would reading your descriptions.

    1. You do have to choose an audiobook carefully. Anything too introspective doesn’t work if you are listening at the same time as say driving, cooking – it’s too easy to lose concentration. Crime does woerk well oddly.

      The early books in the Louise Penny series are enjoyable. Worth giving them a go

      1. Thank you – I’ll see what my library has.

  7. I think I’m done with the Gamache series as well. At least I’ll never buy one again and always use the library in case of future FOMO so I can DNF without regret!

    1. I don’t necessarily want a cosy story – or one just set in Three Pines – but there must surely be a middle ground?

      1. Yes! Enough with the terrorism!

        1. And enough with the duck! Isn’t it time it turned up on the bistro menu???

        2. 😂😂😂

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading