Book ReviewsScottish authors

The Illuminations by Andrew O’Hagan [2015 Man Booker Longlist]

The IlluminationsThe secrets we keep from each other but often even from ourselves: caught in their protective web of deception the cast of characters in Andrew O’Hagan’s The Illuminations are people who find varying levels of enlightenment.

Octogenarian Anne Quirk is one of the deceivers. In a sheltered home in Scotland, she is succumbing to dementia, deemed unsafe to cook for herself or let anywhere near an electric oven. Under the watchful eye of her kindly neighbour Maureen, Anne’s internal conflict with the past comes to life through disconnected fragments of memories and stacks of photographs. They reveal she was a ground breaking photographer in her younger days whose work “captured a world beyond the obvious.” It’s not until her beloved grandson returns from his tour of duty in Afghanistan and takes her back to a Blackpool guesthouse, that the secrets of Anne’s life are illuminated. Only then does it seem that she can be at peace.

As his grandmother tries to remember the long-ago past, Luke is trying to put his own past behind him. He’s returned to Scotland, a disillusioned young man whose army career is over as a result of a catastrophic episode when he was part of a convoy in Helmand province. Through some fast-paced chapters set in Afghanistation it becomes clear that the episode represented an epiphany for Luke; the moment he acknowledged to himself that he had joined the army purely to find the kind of man he hoped his father, who died serving his country, had been. For years he’d buried this knowledge beneath a cloak of camaraderie with the men under his command, smoking marijuana and listening to heavy metal while they patrolled the desert for booby traps. But the increasingly erratic behaviour of his commanding officer strips him of his illusions.

Not all the characters in O’Hagan’s novel encounter anything comparable to the illuminating moments that Luke and Anne experience. Maureen for example is clearly a woman who’s concocted a deceit about her relationship with her children. She regularly boasts about her children and and how much success they’ve made of their lives (blithely ignoring the fact that one of them is an alcoholic). She regularly complains that they are always too busy to visit her — yet when they do, she clearly can’t stand them and cannot wait for them to leave.

The slow paced contemplative sections of the novel contrast with the sections on the front line which blaze with action and vivid dialogue. O’Hagan seems very comfortable handling both the very male world of the army with its obscenity laden, swaggering dialogue and the domestic rituals of the women in the home. He effortlessly moves from the small and often humorous observation:  “It was a constant battle in Maureen’s head, the wonder of central heating versus the benefit of fresh air…” to bigger issues of the ethics of foreign military intervention or the fractured parent/child relationship. He also deals sensitively, though not sentimentally, with Anne’s dementia describing it not as the shutting down of a life but the re-awakening of an old one. Anne’s estranged daughter Alice tells her doctor she wishes she could spend half an hour with her mother as a young woman. “She hasn’t gone,” he whispered. “Quite the opposite. She’s coming back. And maybe you could prepare to meet her half-way. Between the person she is now Andy the person she used to be.

This ability to flex between the macro and the microcosm could be one of the reasons the judges of the Man Booker Prize chose it for the 2015 longlist. Will it make it to the final accolade or will this be third time unlucky for O’Hagan? My sense is it’s not the winner. The sections dealing with Anne are well observed but not remarkable so the strength of the novel really rests on the Afghanistan chapters. Without those for me this would have been an Ok novel but with them it’s one that’s well worth reading.

End Notes

The Illuminations is published by Faber.

Andrew O’Hagan is a Scottish novelist, non-fiction author and an editor of Esquire and the London Review of Books. He currently works as a a creative writing fellow at King’s College London.


What do you need to know about me? 1. I'm from Wales which is one of the countries in the UK and must never be confused with England. 2. My life has always revolved around the written and spoken word. I worked as a journalist for nine years then in international corporate communications 3. My tastes in books are eclectic. I love realism and hate science fiction and science fantasy. 4. I am trying to broaden my reading horizons geographically by reading more books in translation

12 thoughts on “The Illuminations by Andrew O’Hagan [2015 Man Booker Longlist]

  • Pingback: Even In The Warmest Glow, How Cold The Shadow…. The Illuminations by Andrew O’Hagan | Inside A Dog

  • Pingback: Company of Rogues #BookReviews #BriFri | Joy's Book Blog

  • joyweesemoll

    Interesting issues to cover in a novel — they would play as effectively to an American audience as a British one, I suspect.

    • Yes I think they would Joy, particularly the Iraq sections.

  • buriedinprint

    I like the sounds of the contrasting tones that you describe; I’ve been “saving” a podcast interview with him and Eleanor Wachtel on CBC’s “Writers & Company” and I think I’ll listen to it now!

    • I’ve not come across that podcast – will have to go looking now. I like exploring different ones…

  • This does sound good. We are trying to read as many as possible before the shortlist so we can try to predict but this one had been lower in my list to get to (it’s doubtful we will be able to read all before the list is announced). So far, we’ve only read Lila (my co-blogger reviewed it) and I’m reading The Green Road now in hopes to post next week. Your review does make it sound much more interesting to me so perhaps I’ll try to get my hands on it next.

    • what do you make of the Green Road? I finished it last week but haven’t posted my thoughts on it yet

      • I haven’t read enough to say yet. I’m am liking it thus far but just started it. I will let you know after the weekend. I will look forward to seeing your review.

      • I saw you posted your review today. I’m not going to look at it until I’m done with the book and have written up my review but I look forward to reading your thoughts. I am about 75% done and like it well enough although I’m not sure it deserves to be on the long list since it is not blowing me away

  • This sounds really good, actually. Definitely getting on my TBR list.

    • its one of those books where I kept remembering parts of it, and thinking about the story, for a few weeks after I finished it


We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: