Book Reviews

The Enchanted April by Elizabeth von Arnim — irresistible charm

Cover of The Enchanted April by Elizabeth von Arnim, a novel that transports readers to the charms of the Italian Riviera

On a dark and gloomy winter day, what a joy it was to be transported to the sunny climes of the Italian Riveria, courtesy of The Enchanted April.

This novel about four women who take a holiday in Portofino, was apparently inspired by Elizabeth von Arnim’s own sojourn in that part of the coastline. Just like her characters, von Arnim was captivated by San Salvatore, a medieval castello on the hillside looking over the fishing village:

Across the bay the lovely mountains, exquisitely different in colour, were asleep too in the light; and underneath her window, at he bottom of the flower-starred grass slope from which the wall of the castle rose up, was a great cypress, cutting through the delicate blues and violets and rose-colours of the mountains and the sea like a great black sword.

In The Enchanted April, the castello and its gardens works its magic on four women who discover each other through an advert in a London newspaper announcing the castle’s availability as a holiday rental.

On a grey, rainy afternoon in February, the promise of sunshine and wisteria is instantly appealing to solicitor’s wife Lottie Wilkins and Rose Arbuthnot, whose husband writes books of which she disapproves. They rope in two other women to help pay the cost of a month’s rental: an elderly widow Mrs Fisher a young socialite Lady Caroline Dester.

These women come from vastly different backgrounds and have nothing in common — or so they believe . But as we discover, they are all nursing unhappiness and dissatisfaction with their lives.

Lottie’s solicitor husband Mellersh is very close-fisted with his cash so she has few funds to buy fashionable clothes and ends up looking, in the eyes of her acquaintances “a perfect fright”. Rose has no financial worries because her husband keeps her flush with money. It’s the source of his income she finds distasteful: the colourful memoirs he writes about king’s mistresses. Rose’s aversion to his work is so strong that that she gives all the money away to the poor. While he’s away leading a secret life in London she devotes her energies to charitable endeavours.

Lady Caroline Dexter has romantic problems of a very different kind. Men just won’t leave her alone; they’re constantly buzzing around her at parties and balls. Tired of the attention and her hectic social life, she retreats to Italy, wanting nothing more than to be left alone to think about her life and her future.

The fourth member of the party is Mrs Fisher, a pompous snob who begins to act as hostess in charge of the holiday and impose her will on the other three women. She lives so much in times long ago when she knew many leading figures in Victorian society that she’s shut herself off from the possibility of new friendships.

San Salvatore works its magic on all four women, causing them to change their perspectives so significantly that they finish the holiday feeling rejuvenated and more hopeful about the future.

The Enchanted April contains wonderful descriptions of the lush gardens surrounding the castello. On their first morning the women throw open their bedroom windows to behold wisteria “tumbling over itself in its excess of life” and terraces lade with fig, peach and cherry trees dropping away to the sea. By the end of the holiday, nature is in even greater profusion, the women departing among a cloud of acacia scent.

No one had noticed how many acacias there were till one day the garden was full of a new scent, and there were the delicate trees, the lovely successors to the wisteria, hung all over among their trembling leaves with blossom … the whole garden dressed itself gradually towards the end in white, and grew more and more scented.

Even more enjoyable however were the portrayals of the four women guests. von Arnim has a keen eye for detail, revealing the nature of these women and their failings subtly but assuredly.

My particular favourite was Mrs Fisher, a formidable woman very fond of mentioning her acquaintance with the likes of John Ruskin and Lord Tennyson. She has such an air of entitlement, not content with bagging the best bedroom, she commandeers the adjacent sitting room; getting the staff to move garden pots and furniture so none of the other women can intrude. But even she, by the end of the narrative, has let the barriers down; even permitting Lottie Wilkins to give her a kiss.

It’s a genial, but not frothy, novel that is rescued from sentimentality by von Arnim’s wit and sense of humour. There’s a really funny scene on the quartet’s first evening meal together when Caroline turns up in a flimsy dress that clings to her body. Lottie is enraptured but Mrs Fisher is aghast when the girl reveals she’s wearing very little underneath, not so much because her prudish sensibilities are offended but because the girl would undoubtedly catch a cold and pass it on.

Mrs Fisher had a great objection to other people’s chills. They were always the fruit of folly; and then they were handed on to her who had done nothing at all to deserve them.

The Enchanted April does lose a bit of its witty edge three quarters of the way through but by then I was too much under the spell to care. The combination of Mediterranean sunshine, scented gardens, medieval Italian castle and four touchingly amusing female companions was irresistible.

An Enchanted April by Elizabeth von Arnim: Footnotes

Despite the German-sounding surname Elizabeth von Arnim wasn’t German. Nor was she called Elizabeth. She was born Mary Annette Beauchamp in Australia, a distant relative of the author who became known as Katherine Mansfield. “Elizabeth” left Australia at the age of three, settling in England with her parents. She married twice, first to a German count and then, after his death, the Earl of Russell. She was a great dinner party hostess, lived in thirty-five different houses and had five children and fourteen dogs.

She wrote her first book  Elizabeth and Her German Garden, in 1898, in which she recorded each season in the garden, she loved, a place she regarded as a refuge from domestic routine and an overbearing husband.

An Enchanted April, published in 1922, became a best-seller in both England and the United States. It created such high levels of interest in Portofino that it became a “must see” holiday destination during the years between the two world wars.

This was book number 30 in my #21 in 21 project in 2021 where I set out to to read more books from the hundreds that lay unread in my bookshelves.


What do you need to know about me? 1. I'm from Wales which is one of the countries in the UK and must never be confused with England. 2. My life has always revolved around the written and spoken word. I worked as a journalist for nine years then in international corporate communications 3. My tastes in books are eclectic. I love realism and hate science fiction and science fantasy. 4. I am trying to broaden my reading horizons geographically by reading more books in translation

41 thoughts on “The Enchanted April by Elizabeth von Arnim — irresistible charm

    • That does sound good Brona. I shall add to my ever expanding wishlist

  • A great review of a wonderfully life-affirming book. I’m so glad you enjoyed this. It really is a tonic in the dark gloomy days of winter, a blast of spring sunshine as we await the new season. I love the way each woman undergoes a transformation of sorts – a shift in their perspective, as you say.

    • The scenes where Mr Wilkins begins to appreciate his wife are quite touching.

  • I will read von Arnim ‘soon’. We keep claiming her as Australian, but not with any great reason that I can see, but nevertheless she appears to be part of the conversation here.

    • I thought she left Australia when she was very young

  • Oh I so love this book. It was my first by Elizabeth von Arnim, now a favourite writer. It’s such a delicious escape to read this one, definitely one I want to reread.

    • I could have guessed you would enjoy this one Ali, it sounds just perfect for you

    • I so wish I had the time to re-read but yes if I did, this would be one on my list too

  • Pingback: Winding Up the Week #209 – Book Jotter

    • Absolutely a treat in which to indulge at the end of the day

  • I read this after watching a rather lovely adapation with a brilliant cast which included Miranda Richardson and Joan Plowright. An absolute delight!

    • Plowright would have been wonderful as Mrs Fisher I suspect

  • I haven’t got a copy, but this book has been on my TBR list for ages. Thanks for giving me a nudge.

    • It took me ages to get around to reading it Margaret – somehow I thought it would be light and frothy but it was nothing of the kind

      • I love this one–a grown up version of the Secret Garden! Glad you enjoyed this.

        • Shall I confess I’ve never read The Secret Garden???

        • Do, it’s a lovely read. One of my favourite books

        • I shall add it to my next classics club list

        • Hope you enjoy it🙂 I’ll keep a look out for your thoughts.

        • Might be a while before I get to it – I do have a tendency to buy far more books than I can possibly read in a year

        • I’m much the same; and having joined NetGalley I’ve gotten all the more ‘greedy’, and also end up reading books from there with ones I bought waiting even longer.

        • I know, I have to really discipline myself not to look at NetGalley

        • As do I. I made the mistake of looking at the Edelweiss catalogue yesterday and ended up with three more books

        • Oh dear. Easily done though. Its still a cheaper hobby than say photography!

  • I was ‘late’ to this book as well and, like you, absolutely loved it.

  • I read this a few years ago and adored it. Thanks for reminding me of its charms. I have also read “Elizabeth and her Garden” which was enjoyable but nowhere near as enchanting as this one!

    • Now I’ve been introduced to von Arnim, I’ve been thinking I should get “Elizabeth and her Garden” . My hesitation is that it will probably make me feel very dissatisfied with my own gardening efforts

      • I’ve read a number of von Arnim’s books — most in the public domain — and there is lots to enjoy. The semi-autobiographical ones are good. Another funny, sunny one is Princess Priscilla’s Fortnight. She also wrote some darker psychological tales like Vera. An author worth exploring, glad you liked this one so much!

        • I love it when there is a whole backlist to explore. Interesting that she changed her style so much to write the darker novels

        • I think her life was not altogether easy … she called her husband The Man of Wrath!

        • I sense there wasn’t much love going on in that relationship

  • piningforthewest

    I love this book. I first read a very old copy of Elizabeth and Her German Garden – by a Lady – years ago, pre internet so it was ages before I even discovered the name of the author. Since then I’ve read most of her books, all well worth reading although ‘Enchanted’ is still my favourite.

    • I’m so glad I started with the one that so many people consider her best.

  • Ohhh, I absolutely love this book. And your quote about catching cold made me giggle. Now I want to reread!

  • Lovely review! I keep running into this recently. I haven’t read it, but I remember the movie fondly

    • I’ve just been looking for a copy of the film version. Seems like its relatively easy to get.


We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: