Thanks to everyone who pitched in with my August lucky dip options. The Diary of a Provincial Lady came out on top so it’s now added to my reading queue.

It’s time now to dip more once into my TBR Book Jar and select three titles that have been gathering dust.

Covers of three novels by Ann Patchett, E F Benson and Philip Hensher

Commonwealth by Ann Patchett

I loved the first book I read by Ann Patchett (Bel Canto) but wasn’t as keen on my second encounter with her work via The Dutch House. Will Commonwealth win me back to her? This novel spans five decades, telling a tale about the fall out from a ,chance encounter at a christening party which has repercussions for four parents and six children.

Secret Lives by E F Benson

It’s a bit of a mystery how I come to have a comic novel from the 1930s on my TBR. Since it’s an e-book version I suspect it’s one I bought late at night when I succumbed to the temptations of a promotional offer. All I know about the author is that he wrote the Mapp and Lucia series (not one I’ve read). Secret Lives apparently hinges on a showdown between two strong-willed and rather ludicrous women, each determined to best the other.

A Small Revolution in Germany by Philip Hensher

This sounds promising. According to the synopsis on Goodreads it’s about a group of teenagers who yearn to change the world. They smash up political meetings; they paint slogans on walls; they long for armed revolution; they argue, exuberantly, until dawn. In the years to follow, they all change their minds, and go into the world. Only one of them remains true to those early passions. He’s the only one who doesn’t become famous.

Which book do you recommend?

Do you have a favourite among these three books?

When I started the book jar lucky dip at the beginning of the year my intention was to read each selected book within two months. In the light of my decision last month to take a more relaxed approach to my reading, I’m now going to give myself an additional month. Whichever book you choose from this trip, will be one i aim to read by end of November.

30 responses to “TBR Book Jar Lucky Dip — September 2024”

  1. Commonwealth was my first Patchett –
    Read just a couple of months ago – and I really loved it. I do mean to read more of her books now, and hope I’m not disappointed

    1. I’ve just started her latest one – Tom Lake – and am enjoying it so far

  2. Commonwealth has been my favourite of Patchett’s – that gets my vote.

    1. That’s interesting to hear Kate. I haven’t heard of anyone as enthusiastic about the book yet

  3. I would say Benson, as I always find his writing funny!

    1. Humour is hit and miss for me in fiction.

  4. Although I’ve read and enjoyed Commonwealth I find Ann Patchett’s books variable.

    1. Well my evidence base is low since I’ve read only two but they were not the same standard so maybe you’re right

  5. I’ve been tempted by Commonwealth, look forward to hearing what you think if you get to it,

    1. It’s one of those books that I bought without being sure I would enjoy it

  6. I don’t know any of these, but my own choice might be the Hensher, which sounds a bit more meaty.

    1. It does sound as if it has a lot of themes to get stuck into

  7. I’ve read the Patchett and the Hensher. Commonwealth is much more like The Dutch House than it is like Bel Canto, so if you liked the latter more, this one might not be for you. (If you want to get back into her work, I’d recommend State of Wonder instead.) The Hensher was genuinely fascinating although I remember virtually nothing of it now, four and a half years later. I’d vote for that one!

    1. Thanks for that insight Elle – there were some aspects of Dutch House I appreciated but I did find the twins irritating.

  8. I haven’t read it, but I vote for Small Rev–sounds interesting.

      1. I could have guessed you’d go for that one….

    1. My vote is for that too.

      1. The book is certainly getting a number of votes

    2. it does doesn’t it!

  9. I haven’t read any of them, but based on the blurbs A Small Revolution in Germany sounds most interesting – I’d be intrigued to hear your views on it.

    1. It feels like it has more substance than the other two

  10. I love the Mapp and Lucia books! You said, All I know about the author is that he wrote the Mapp and Lucia series (not one I’ve read). Secret Lives apparently hinges on a showdown between two strong-willed and rather ludicrous women, each determined to best the other.

    That is a good description for Mapp and Lucia! The tv series is a lot of fun, with the wonderful Nigel Hawthorne and a well known cast.

    1. I didn’t know there was a tv series. Could be interesting since I’m also a Hawthorne fan

  11. I loved Commonwealth! But I also loved the Dutch House so maybe our tastes are different

    1. I didn’t have a strong dislike of Dutch House, it was just that it didn’t have as much astmosphere as Bel Canto and I wasn’t as heavily invested in the characters

  12. I read Commonwealth but didn’t love it because dysfunctional family drama isn’t my fav. Others have loved it. I think it’s interesting that she drew heavily on her own family of origin experiences for this one. 😢

    1. I didn’t know there was a family connection with this book

  13. Good luck with your September title. I can only say I was super disappointed by Commonwealth

    1. It seems to have strongly divided opinions

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading