I’ve dipped into the TBR Book Jar to find three new titles from which I’ll pick one to read by end of May.

Three novels selected from my Book Jar that I might read in the next month

The Fountain Overflows by Rebecca West

I bought this shortly after reading her short but intense debut novel Return of the Soldier. The Fountain Overflows is a semi-autobiographical novel that reflects on the cultural, historical and psychological elements of the first decade of the 20th century, reflected through the prism of the gifted, eccentric Aubrey family. It was one of her last books and was meant to be the first part of a trilogy but she was never satisfied with the second and third parts so they were never published in her lifetime.

There Were Many Horses by Luiz Ruffato

This is one of the first books I requested via NetGalley, so long ago that I can’t remember anything about the book other than the author is Brazilian. From Goodreads I learn that it’s set in São Paulo in 2000.

As Luiz Ruffato describes the scenes around him on this one typical day, he deciphers every minute and second of a metropolis marked by diversity―a mosaic of people from all over Brazil and the world that defines São Paulo’s personality at the start of the twenty-first century. The city is more than just traffic jams, parks, and global financial maneuvering. It is alive, and every rat and dusty grocery truck informs its distinctive character. ”

That blurb doesn’t give any indication that there is a plot to this novel. Reading some of the reviews posted on Goodreads it seems to be more of a documentary about a city, one that uses poetry, stream of consciousness, and non-literary techniques.

Winter by Ali Smith

This is where I discover a flaw in the Book Jar experiment. Winter is the second title in Ali Smith’s “seasonal” quartet but since I’ve yet to read the first — Autumn — I’d be reading them out of order. So here’s my dilemma: I have other titles in my jar that are part of series so could well end up with the same problem in the future. Should I remove all the series titles from the jar??

And the vote goes to …….Rebecca West

Not a difficult decision to make this time around. West wins on the basis that I already know she’s a talented writer, particularly when dealing with the psychologies of her characters.

10 responses to “TBR Book Jar Lucky Dip — March 2024”

  1. Can you substitute Autumn for Winter? I think that’s what I would do with series books – they’re your rules! Or do what Mary Daniels Brown said and keep in the title of the first book and take out the rest of the series. I’ve read Autumn, it’s a remarkable book.

    1. Thanks for the idea Margaret. I’m not sure I would have picked Ali Smith anyway – she’s an author I’m in two minds about

  2. I’m also enjoying using a TBR Book Jar. I’ve decided that I’ll include not just books I’ve recently purchased, but also ones on my shelf that I never got to reading! (But I’ll still buy more books!)

    1. My jar includes all the books I have bought but have yet to read – in some cases they’ve been waiting more than 8 years for me to read them

  3. I’ll be interested to see how you get on with Ali Smith. I had to read Autumn for the Booktube Prize back in 2020 I believe it was. I hated that experience so much. I only have one other book by Smith to try How to Be Both. If that one doesn’t work for me I won’t be picking up anymore of her books. Good luck!

    1. I did enjoy How to Be Both but I tried another book by her (can’t remember the name now) and wasn’t as enamoured by it.

  4. For what it’s worth, here’s my suggestion for your Book Jar Lucky Dip dilemma: I’d keep in the title of the first book in each series but remove all subsequent books. That way, any series title you pull out will be the first in that series.

    1. That’s a great idea. Wish I’d thought of that when I typed and cut out all those tiny bits of paper – now I have to go through them and take out the series ones!

  5. I’ve only read a little West but it was impressive so I suspect I would have gone with that choice too!

    1. Interesting to find yesterday that she had a tremendous career as a journalist/editorial writer in between writing her novels

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading