Book ReviewsBritish authorshistorical fiction

Now We Shall be Entirely Free by Andrew Miller [book review]

Now We Shall be Entirely Free is an atmospheric adventure tale, set at the height of the Napoleonic wars, that won me over right from the opening page.

It begins with an unconscious man travelling by coach through a rain-drenched English countryside. He is Captain John Lacroix, son of a wealthy Somerset family, who has returned home from a disastrous campaign against Napoleon’s forces in Spain. He’d set off for the war full of optimism and splendidly equipped with new (and expensive) leather boots, a pelisse with fur-lined collar and numerous shirts, waistcoats and neckties.

He returns in borrowed and patched clothes, his feet bound with strips of cloth and his hearing damaged. He is a broken man.

Like the clothes he had arrived in, the pack was not his own. … this one had the look of something raked out of the fire. Scorched, filthy. Black with tar or grease, the world’s filth.

He’s nursed from the brink of death by his housekeeper. But he is clearly a man changed physically and mentally by his experience of war.  It’s not until much later in the novel that we discover the cause of his breakdown: an atrocity committed in a quiet mountain village while the British army was in retreat.

When a fellow officer turns up at the house with instructions for John to return to his return, he flees to Scotland. What he doesn’t know is that some time earlier in Spain a military committee held to inquire into the atrocity decided that someone must be held responsible. They determine Lacroix is that someone. So they despatch a British officer called Calley to find and kill him. .

Lacroix’s escape and Calley’s pursuit sets up the dramatic focus of the novel. Will the regiment catch up with Lacroix before Calley? How long can Lacroix survive on his own wits (the signs are not good because almost as soon as he sets foot in Scotland he is robbed and beaten). The suspense is maintained throughout by alternating Lacroix’s narrative with that of Calley and his companion Medina, a Spanish officer.

Miller excels at creating atmosphere and characters. Calley is the most interesting. He’s a man entirely devoid of principles. A man on a mission to kill. He thinks nothing of torturing and beating up the people he believes have information that will help him track down his quarry. He tells one of his victims:

You want to know who I am? I’ll tell you who I am. I am the war. Yes? And today the war has come to you. It has come right into your house and struck you down.

But in one moment of candour he tells how he learned from an early age how to take care of himself. Working as a piecer in a cotton mill as a child, he would crawl underneath the machines to clean them. One slip and he’d lose his fingers or have his arm ripped off.

While Now We Shall be Entirely Free is certainly an adventure story, there is an element of romance. When Lacroix hides out in the Scottish Hebrides he encounters the Fender siblings, a small community of free thinkers.  Lacroix is enthralled by one of the sisters, Emily, accompanying her to Glasgow for a highly risky operation she hopes will restore her failing sight.  Miller fortunately spares us some of the more gruesome details of the procedure.

The budding romance, which is quite touching in its gentleness and innocence provides a lovely counter to the darkness of the war and the theme of culpability.  Early on in the novel a shadowy officer involved in the military query observes that “No ancient and honourable institution is without its ancient and honourable crimes.”   Lacroix himself is pushed by the Fenders, who do not believe in violence, to question his motives for becoming a soldier. He has to admit he had thought more about the uniform than the fact he would be expected to kill.

If he can evade Calley, will his love for Emily enable Lacroix to put aside his memories of the war? The ending of the novel is deliciously ambivalent. I’m not going to spoil other readers’ enjoyment by revealing the details.

Why I read this book

I loved an earlier novel by Andrew Miller – Pure – which is set in Paris and thought it was superb. So I was more than happy to get a copy of his newest novel from Netgalley in return for an honest review


What do you need to know about me? 1. I'm from Wales which is one of the countries in the UK and must never be confused with England. 2. My life has always revolved around the written and spoken word. I worked as a journalist for nine years then in international corporate communications 3. My tastes in books are eclectic. I love realism and hate science fiction and science fantasy. 4. I am trying to broaden my reading horizons geographically by reading more books in translation

18 thoughts on “Now We Shall be Entirely Free by Andrew Miller [book review]

  • Pingback: Wrapping up 2018 | BookerTalk

  • Love your reference to the deliciously ambivalent ending – I’m still mulling over it – both possibilities feel like they would be okay and a fitting conclusion to the story.

  • It sounds like an interesting evocation of the era – love the comment about joining the war because of the uniform – but it’s probably not high priority for me given all the books I have waiting for me to read.

    • It’s a period about which I knew very little so I enjoyed that aspect too. Perfectly understand that it doesn’t rise to the top of your book tower

  • Jonathan

    I read his first book when it came out but none since then. I mean to read Pure somewhen. This one sounds fascinating as well.

    • Pure is just superb…. if it comes to a question whether to read that or his new one, I would go for Pure

      • Jonathan

        Thanks for the advice. I have a copy of Pure so that will probably be my next one. He seems to cover subject matters and time periods that appeal to me.

  • I think a friend of mine would like this as she has enjoyed some of Andrew Miller’s other books (particularly Ingenious Pain and Pure). He seems to be at his best when he delves deeply into these historical periods.

    • I know Susan Osborne (A Life in Books) thought this one was even better than Pure. I still prefer Pure myself but for sure Miller is a brilliant historical fiction author

    • Absolutely Cathy. It just oozes with atmosphere. As I was reading it I couldn’t get the smell of the cemetery and all those dead bodies out of my system….

  • I thought Calley was the most interesting character too – his childhood experiences in the cotton mill certainly inured him to violence and brutality.

    • I was glad Miller had introduced that aspect so that we saw Calley not just as a one dimensional bad guy

  • Deliciously ambivalent indeed! I’m pleased to hear that you enjoyed this, Karen. I’d loved to have seen it on the Man Booker longlist.

    • the judges seem to be going for non linear kinds of stories so I fear this would have been too safe for them


We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.