The uneasy relationship between humankind and the animal world is just one of the many issues explored in Happiness.

Coyotes, wolves, urban foxes, paraqueets are all under threat in Aminatta’s novel. They represent a menace in the eyes of humans; a threat that must be eradicated by all possible means — legally or illegally. Farmers view the creatures as threats to their livestock and in the cities, popular opinion maintains that urban foxes spread disease. So foxes are culled, coyotes and wolves hunted and the tree habitats of nesting parakeets cut down and their eggs destroyed.

But yet they survive. There’s a lovely passage towards the end of the novel when Jean — one of the two protagonists — spies a small colony of parakeets in a dead tree she can see from her garden. Survivors of a cull in a nearby cemetery.

.. a parakeet glides from one branch to another where a second parakeet perches. They rest there for a moment, then take off in unison, joined by six or seven others, to fly across the city, who knows to which parks, gardens and squares. The only thing she knows is this: come dusk they will return.

it’s a message of hope in Happiness; a novel that has an underlying theme about survivors and outsiders.

Jean is a wildlife expert from Massachusetts who has set up home in London while she conducts study into urban foxes. Her funding from the European Commission is meagre so she’s forced to find another income stream by designing rooftop gardens.

One evening while she’s tracking a fox she collides with the bulky figure of Attila Asare, a Ghanian psychiatrist. He’s in London to speak at a conference about his experience in working with traumatised victims of war. The first encounter is brief but their paths continue to cross afterwards; their lives, slowly becoming more and more entwined.

Happiness has a complex plot involving Attila’s niece who has been arrested as a suspected illegal immigrant, and her son who has gone missing. There is also a thread about Attila’s former colleague and lover who is in a care home and showing signs of dementia. And of course there’s the question of whether his relationship with Jean will blossom into romance.

It’s a lot to fit into one novel, rather too much I felt. So some issues — such as the generalised assumptions about the psychological effect of trauma — don’t get the attention they deserve.

To add to the complexity there are multiple flashbacks which flesh out the details of events in Attilla and Jean’s lives. Some cover Attila’s experiences in Bosnia, Sierra Leone and Iraq and the sudden death of his wife. Others relate the disintegration of Jean’s marriage and her frustrations when her attempts to protect wild animals see her ridiculed and labelled “mad”.

The flow of the narrative is further interrupted by chapters which detail attempts throughout history to eradicate coyotes and wolves. If you’re particularly interested in the habits of various members of the canidae family, then you’ll love those interludes. but I found my attention wavering each time.

Of far more interest was Forna’s depiction of the underbelly of life in London. Street sweepers, security guards, kitchen staff and hotel doormen are all recruited by Jean to help her track and record sitings of urban foxes. They prove invaluable in finding and comforting the missing boy.

it made a refreshing change to read about the people who oil the machinery of the city. Their efforts at keeping buildings safe, the streets clean and litter bins emptied are seldom recognised nor openly appreciated. In fiction they’re often given short shrift but in Forna’s novel. these “outsiders” who fled war in their own countries, are brought wonderfully to life. They’re shown as people who have retained a sense of perspective even when confronted by finicky hotel and restaurant guests.

There are those who will not eat vegetables and those who will not eat meat, and those who only eat uncooked food … Others will eat no solid food and want special juices … we can make any kind our customers want, with kale and carrot and wheatgerm, celery, special ingredients say spirulina, seaweed for them that is ‘detoxing’ Whatever, whatever.

I’d have enjoyed the novel more if we could have spent even more time with these individuals, witnessing their quiet dignity and their capacity for small acts of human kindness. As it was, I finished the novel believing that Aminatta Forna is a writer who can vividly portray characters and a whole city but gets too swept along by the potential of all the ideas buzzing around in her head.

20 responses to “Happiness by Aminata Forna — the underbelly of a city”

  1. […] my next life, I want to have: Happiness by Aminatta […]

  2. I’m sorry I’ve been so absent lately – and by lately I mean for a long time. My parents’ deaths and COVID, the birth of grandchildren in another city, the big downsize, etc, have wrought havoc on my blogging life, something I’m struggling to recover. Let’s see if I can.

    I have read Forna’s The hired man which I really liked, and always intended to read more, but have I? No? It was a book about outsiders too, though I don’t think I actually expressed it that way in my review!

    1. I think you’ve had plenty of things on your plate far more important than reading my blog! My blogging life has also been thrown into chaos but for very different reasons – I’ve become so enthusiastic about my new hobby of quilting that I simply don’t have the time to write or to read other blogs. Maybe that will change when the enthusiasm wears off.

      Interesting to hear that about Forna – I’m not absolutely sure whether I want to read anything more by her. We’ll see

  3. I remember Simon Savidge raving about this book; interesting to hear a counter point of view.

    1. No-one in our book club was a fan of the book. We all felt parts of it were good but it was too jumbled

  4. Definitely sounds like it needed paring down a bit…

    1. Absolutely. She did try to cram too many elements into it – the whole thing about the boy going missing was unecessary

  5. This sounds interesting but it does seem that she’s tried to include too much. I have read The Memory of Love, which is set in Sierra Leone after the civil war, and I didn’t particularly enjoy that one, so I’m not sure if I will try any of her others.

    1. I think I have a copy of that lurking somewhere. I felt she writes really well so I haven’t been put off reading something else by her

  6. I really enjoyed The Hired Man – the only novel I have read by Forna. This one sounds less successful, but still full of interesting ideas.

    1. I’ve not heard of that one – was it an early book from her?

      1. 2013 I think. Here you are: https://aminattaforna.com/the-hired-man.html. I found it an immersive multi-layered read.

        1. Thanks for the link Margaret. It does sound interesting

  7. I’m reminded of the Emperor’s words to Mozart after a performance of his opera, rendered in the film Amadeus in this way: “It’s quality work. And there are simply too many notes, that’s all. Just cut a few and it will be perfect.” Substitute “ideas” for “notes” here perhaps? It still sounds like quality work, though!

    1. That’s a line from the film that we use often in our household! Yes the writing quality was high but got lost in all the plots/sub plots

  8. This does sound as if too many themes hae been crammed into what could otherwise have been a very good novel. I remember reading The Memory of Love back in the days when I had to read some books for work. So long ago that I don’t remember much about it but haven’t read anything else by her since.

    1. The fact you didn’t go on to read anything else by her suggests to me that Memory of Love wasn’t a great hit with you.

  9. Interesting… I have the one from before this one, The Hired Man, but I hadn’t heard anything about this one and her most recent one is a venture into NF which I hadn’t heard about either.
    Maybe I haven’t been paying enough attention!

    1. The only other one I’ve heard of is The Memory of Love which I have a feeling is the book she is best known for.

      1. Yes, I think so too.

We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading