Book Reviews

The Long Dry by Cynan Jones — nuance portrait of strained relationship

Cover image of The Long Dry, a novella by the Welsh author Cynan Jones.

In The Long Dry, a farmer walks his parched fields in search of a calving cow who has gone AWOL. While Gareth is out tramping through woodland and bog on a long, hot and arid summer day,  his wife lies in bed with one of her frequent migraines. 

Not the most exciting of plot summaries is it? 

Yet from this simple starting point, Cynan Jones weaves an exceptionally tense tale of emotional isolation and a marriage that is crumbling in silence and misunderstanding. It’s a topic that is treated sympathetically but not sentimentally.

The Long Dry is told largely from Gareth’s perspective as he searches for his errant beast.  We learn of worries that his relationship with his wife Kate is coming apart. They seldom talk to each other now, suppressed anger and frustration bubbling beneath their encounters. 

Gareth misses the carefree woman with whom he fell in love. He still loves her, wants her to understand that the physical changes in her body don’t matter to him.

The places of her that give softly when he holds her; that have changed and shifted through the years, as if titling with the changes of his own flesh, to be in tune still, as if he was the hard land and she the water that would always know it, however it changed.

He wants the old Kate back and as he walks through the fields, he fantasises about abandoning his search for the cow and rekindling the spontaneous joy of their early years together.  

But he’s afraid. His wife suffered multiple miscarriages in their life together, each one causing her to unravel. He doesn’t know if he has the strength to go through that again. So he turns his back on any declaration of love and sets off once more on his search.  

Unspoken Love

At times the point of view shifts to Kate whose interior monologue reveals the source of her own silent suffering to be a one-time lapse of judgment. Her subsequent guilt triggered migraine attacks and caused her to begin cutting herself.  

She still loves her husband but worries that her feelings are no longer reciprocated because her body is beginning to sag. She never tells him of her feelings, putting more physical space between them by spending hours alone in her bedroom. Tasks she would previously have shared with her husband are now left to him alone to handle or to her young daughter.

It’s a very intense narrative, with all the action taking place in the farmhouse and the surrounding fields.  The outside world intrudes only in fragments— a neighbour ploughs his field;  two unnamed boys find an injured rabbit on a bank; the vet arrives to examine the family dog.  The two children of the household, teenage son Dylan and young daughter Emmy, also feature briefly.

We also get to hear from the cow herself as she roams through woodland and bog, driven crazy by heat, thirst and flies.

She was walking on, trying to find a trough of water thinking I’ll walk on for a while but I ould just lay down and sleep and she didn’t know where she was. She had he droll, shaking head of an idiot. She was thinking about crashing herself into the bank and the fence to be insensibele and get out of the heat. and of doing things cows shouldn’t ….

This novella has an unusual structure. It’s delivered in very short chapters headed with different aspects of the farm or moments from the lives of each family member. So we get “Ducks”, “The Mole”, “The Farmhand” and “The Vet”, tied into a unified narrative by the plot line of the search for the cow. 

There are broader themes as Gareth reflects on his father’s efforts to establish the farm and what legacy he will be able to pass on to his own children. But we keep returning to the relationship between these individuals and whether it can endure.  There’s a suggestion at the end that there may be some lessoning of the tension between Gareth and Kate but if that is the case, it could be temporary. As readers we have been given privileged information of a heart-breaking incident that will very soon test the strength of their couple still further.

Rich in symbolism

This is the first novel published by Welsh author Cynan Jones and it bears the hallmarks of his later work: closely observed detail; sparse sentences, evocative language rich in symbolism and an affinity with the rhythms of nature. 

Over the hills behind the farm the light started. Just a thinning of the very black night that made the stars twinkle more, vibrate like a bird’s throat, and put out a light loud compared to their tininess.

Often the significance and meaning of the symbolism isn’t obvious. It’s easy to work out that the “long dry” of the title relates both to the weather and the arid state of the couple’s relationship. But the symbolism of the cow isn’t as straightforward.

It is a metaphor for the missing element in the couple’s relationship? Something that can only be discovered with effort? Is there a connection between the cow’s her pregnancy and Kate’s miscarriages? Why is it a cow that goes missing — would it have made any difference if it had been a different animal?

Numerous questions but the fact that there are no clear cut answers and an ambiguous ending. adds to the pleasure of reading this book. It’s a beautifully nuanced portrait of the strains in a marriage conveyed in sentences that flow so elegantly and poetically you catch your breath at their beauty.


What do you need to know about me? 1. I'm from Wales which is one of the countries in the UK and must never be confused with England. 2. My life has always revolved around the written and spoken word. I worked as a journalist for nine years then in international corporate communications 3. My tastes in books are eclectic. I love realism and hate science fiction and science fantasy. 4. I am trying to broaden my reading horizons geographically by reading more books in translation

11 thoughts on “The Long Dry by Cynan Jones — nuance portrait of strained relationship

  • Pingback: March 2022 Reading Wrap Up : BookerTalk

  • I loved this book when I read it years and years ago. I think the pregnant cow is symbolic of his wife; he is desperate to save her.

    I have also read The Dig, which I loved, but wasn’t enamoured of Stillicide…

    • That symbolism does make sense Kim. I’m waiting for Stillcide to become available in the library – it seems a very different kind of book for him to have written.

  • I really liked The Dig when I read it a couple of years ago. Such beautiful prose, very poetic despite the fairly dark subject matter. I’m sure I would appreciate this too as it seems to be in a similar vein.

    • From what I’ve heard of The Dig, it is more stark than the Long Dry. It’s on my list to read though along with his latest one Stillcide which seems a departure from the farming theme

  • Oh this sounds too traumatic for me, but also sounds like it is well done and deserves to do well out in the world. I’m not sure I can face books about other people also sagging at the moment!!

    • Luckily nothing awful happens to the cow but if you’re feeling a bit fragile yourself at the moment then this book isn’t going to cheer you exactly

      • If the cow doesn’t do it, the sagging and infertility will! Not one for me but I’m glad it’s out there in the world if you know what I mean!

  • What a title; not unlike the long stretch…anyhow, how to not read into things when reading such a book? We all know how to dispel things above that of another in the room or not. It is a good review and I am sorry for always taking things for more than meant to be. Keep reading on!

    • It’s true, its hard to avoid thinking that everything has another meaning


We're all friends here. Come and join the conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: