Double Trouble— Reviews of Jane Harper & Louise Penny
My review back log gets longer by the week. In an effort to catch up I’m going to batch a few together. First on the scene are two crime novels by authors whose work I’ve read in the past.
Force of Nature by Jane Harper
I’ve endured many a corporate team-building exercise during my career. Mercifully none as arduous or fractious as the one featured in Force of Nature.
This is a follow up to her debut novel The Dry which I loved for its claustrophobic atmosphere of life in a small rural town in Australia during a prolonged drought. Force of Nature is no less atmospheric, though this time we’re in the hostile bushland of the Giralang Ranges on a very wet weekend.
Five employees from the accountancy conglomerate BaileyTennants, head out into the bush in an exercise designed to build camaraderie. Only four return. Of the missing woman, Alice Russell, there is no trace despite an extensive search and rescue mission.
Her disappearance has a special significance for Aaron Falk, the police officer introduced in The Dry. He’s now part of a police financial investigation unit in Melbourne where he’s working on a major case involving BaileyTennants. Alice is a key witness, an insider who can get him vital documents to prove various fraudulent dealings by the company.
So the question is whether Alice’s whistleblower activities are somehow connected to her disappearance. She sounded desperate in a voice message she left for him shortly before she went missing. Has she done a runner to avoid having to give evidence or is she the victim of a crime? Throw in the unsolved disappearance of another girl and a notorious killer connected to this bushland area, and you have the recipe for a tension-laden mystery.
Haroer’s narrative skilfully navigates past and present in alternating chapters that become shorter as the book reaches the climax.
The present-day thread is very much a police procedural while the past relates details of the expedition. Underlying tensions between the five women come to the surface when they lose their way. With dwindling food and water supplies, and no consensus on how to get out of this mess, caustic and snide remarks escalate into violent arguments.
While the Force of Nature wasn’t quite as compelling as The Dry it’s still a very strong second novel. I’m now looking forward to reading Exiles which is the the third (and apparently final) novel to feature Aaron Falk
All the Devils are Here by Louise Penny
For the 16th novel in her Chief Inspector Gamache series, Louise Penny transports her chief investigator from his usual stamping ground in the villages and cities of Quebec province, to the streets of Paris. All the Devils are Here sees Armand Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie on a visit to see their children and await the birth of a new grand-child.
The visit gets off to a horrific start. As the couple leave a family dinner at a favourite bistro, Armand’s billionaire godfather is knocked down and critically injured. Armand is certain this was no accident but who would want to kill the old man and why?
Though he has no authority to investigate, that doesn’t stop Armand pushing for the truth. He’s aided by his son-in-law Jean-Guy Beauvioir who is now living in Paris and working for a private engineering corporation. They encounter lies, deceit and conspiracies that put the whole family in danger.
I enjoyed the change in location. Though the village of Three Pines (home to the Gamache family) is delightful and charming, some of the villagers can be a touch annoying. The Paris setting means we are mercifully spared the grumpy poet Ruth and her blasted duck. I’m also more than happy to trade Parisienne patisseries and moules for the hot chocolate and pancakes served at the Three Pines bistro.
The books in this series to date have been noticeable for plots that are more than just exciting crime mysteries. Penny uses them to explore relationships, behaviours and attitudes. All the Devils are Here doesn’t disappoint in that regard.
In previous novels, Armand’s son Daniel has largely stayed in the background , the source of tension between him and his father mentioned but not explained. This novel gets to the heart of the issue, revealing mistakes, misunderstandings and unspoken fears. Through faltering attempts at a reconciliation we see a side to Armand that hasn’t been in evidence previously.
The father/son relationship and the poignant ending lift this book above your standard crime fiction novel.


Calmgrove
Authors whose names are new to me, Karen, I have to admit (or rather, since you’ve reviewed previous titles by them, authors whose names I’d forgotten or failed to register. Ooer… ). Would I commit to a crime fiction series though while I have one or two already on the go? I rather fear not, regardless of the qualities you point out.
BookerTalk
I can relate – I have been reading the Louise Penny series for about 10 years
FictionFan
I thought Force of Nature was the weakest of her books, although still enjoyable. But I felt Exiles was back up to the standard of The Dry, so you have something to look forward to!
hopewellslibraryoflife
Good reviews. I liked both books.
Carol
I loved the happy ending Falk received in Exiles!
All the Devils was one of my favs of the series…the ending was great!
BookerTalk
Now. you have me intrigued by Exiles.
I’ve just finished the most recent Louise Penny – think it will be my last. The series has gone in a direction I don’t particularly care for
Carol
Same re Penny….i decided I would wait for a library hold…I’m done buying them. I haven’t enjoyed one in a while.
The best part of Exiles is the HEA for Falk!
Cathy746books
I loved The Dry! Didn’t realise that she had done a follow up.
BookerTalk
Ah then you. have that pleasure to come. Force of Nature puts more flesh on the bones of the character of Aaron
margaret21
If the Penny isn’t set in that super-annoying Three Pines, I’m in! Also I’ve only so far read- and enjoyed – one Jane Harper, so you’ve tempted me.
BookerTalk
I loved Three Pines in the early books but now it feels like she is ticking boxes. So every time she mentions the village she has to tell us a) about the significance of the pines b) what they eat at the bistro and 3) the blasted duck
margaret21
Quite. Enough is enough.